Just as Millennials and Gen Zers in the United States have lamented hedge funds and short sellers who are part of the Wall Street elite, many small Chinese investors have lamented what they see as market exploitation by large institutions.
The financial markets in mainland China are very different from those in New York. Missing sales are extremely regulated and incredibly rare, which makes it difficult Chinese investors to reproduces the US frenzy that has accumulated GameStop shares as a way to stick it to hedge funds that looked like the company’s shares would collapse.
Mother and pop investors often complain that they are harvested as “leeks” – a “common vegetable in the Chinese diet” – by big players cheating them out of the money they think they deserve. (The government can sometimes be the target of this anger, too, if the wider market is doing poorly.)
Chinese investors could, in theory, try to collectively raise the price of an individual share and then drop it before institutional investors do so. But this is a high order, given the resources and knowledge that large shareholders have. And institutional firms that focus on long transactions may eventually benefit from share increases.
Hard to replicate
Dictating major changes in the market is “theoretically” achievable for individual Chinese investors, said Kenny Tang, CEO of Royston Securities, a Hong Kong brokerage firm, given their familiarity with using social media chat rooms to bet. on individual shares.
“You can imagine that it is not difficult for some of them to unite and have an influence on individual shares, especially small capitals,” Tang said.
Analysts warn, however, that coordinated trading in a country like China, where everything is highly regulated, is fraught with danger.
“If you get the attention of regulators, it probably won’t end well for you,” said Tang, who added that people trying to organize large market fluctuations risk being arrested if the government suspects them of stock market manipulation.
Others, such as retail investor Luke Chen, are not really sold on the idea of an amateur revolution in China because of the more professional knowledge that established investment firms have.
“Individual investors are much less strong than large investors in terms of capital size, investing knowledge – even some trading applications are optimized exclusively better for large investors,” said Chen, who is based in Shanghai.